A teacher, an app or on your own?

A fair look at apps, recorded lessons and live teachers: what each does well, and the one thing only a teacher can do.

First steps4 min read

Written and reviewed by Dr. Rami Mus’ab Mohamed

A girl on a floor cushion puts on headphones for an online lesson while her mother tilts the laptop towards her.A girl on a floor cushion puts on headphones for an online lesson while her mother tilts the laptop towards her.

Apps help; a teacher checks

You can learn a lot on your own: the names of the letters, the sound of a surah (chapter of the Qur’an), the meaning of a rule of tajweed (the rules for pronouncing each letter and sound of the Qur’an correctly). What you cannot easily do on your own is find out whether your reading is right. For that you need someone who listens to you and corrects you.

So the honest answer is not “teacher or app”. Apps and recordings are useful tools. A teacher is the person who checks that what you have learnt is correct. Most learners, and almost all children, need both.

Why reading needs someone to hear you

The Qur’an has always been passed on by hearing and being heard. A student listens to a teacher recite and recites it back, and the teacher corrects them until the reading is sound. This way of learning is called talaqqi (receiving the Qur’an from a teacher, face to face), and it is the agreed, traditional way the Qur’an has been taught across generations.

The Companions learnt in the same way, directly from the Prophet ﷺ:

‘Abdullah ibn Mas‘ud said: “By Allah, I learnt more than seventy surahs directly from the mouth of the Messenger of Allah ﷺ.”

Sahih al-Bukhari 5000

There is a practical reason too. Many mistakes in reading are hard to hear in your own voice: a short vowel stretched too long, a heavy letter said lightly, two similar letters such as ح and ه mixed up. You can read the same line a hundred times and repeat the same mistake each time. A teacher hears it the first time.

What apps and recordings do well

It is worth being fair to apps and recorded lessons. Used well, they help a great deal:

  • Listening. Hearing a skilled reciter again and again trains the ear, and helps with memorising the Qur’an.
  • Revision. Going over a page or a surah between lessons keeps it fresh.
  • Explanation. A recorded lesson can explain a tajweed rule clearly, and you can replay it as often as you need.
  • Flexibility. They are there at any hour, which helps busy families and adults.

What they cannot do is listen to you with understanding, notice exactly where your reading went wrong and show you how to put it right. Some tools give a score for your recitation, but a score is not a correction, and it can miss mistakes or flag ones that are not there.

Live lessons or recorded lessons?

Recorded courses and live lessons are often compared on price and convenience. The more useful question is: who corrects the reading?

Live and recorded lessons compared
Live lesson with a teacherRecorded lesson or app
Hears your recitationYes, every time you readNo
Corrects mistakesAs they happenOnly if you notice them yourself
Adjusts the paceTo the learner, lesson by lessonFixed; you choose what to watch
Explains a ruleYes, and checks you have understoodYes, and you can replay it
Available any timeAt a set time each weekYes
Keeps a child engagedA person who responds to themDepends on the child and the tool

“Live” only helps if the lesson is truly two-way. A live class where a teacher recites to a large group and no one reads aloud is closer to a recording. One-to-one lessons give the most time for the learner to read and be corrected.

When learning on your own works, and when it doesn’t

Self-study works well when:

  • You are revising something a teacher has already checked.
  • You are listening to a reciter to learn how a surah sounds.
  • You are reading about the meaning of a rule before your teacher practises it with you.
  • You already read accurately and want to keep up your reading between lessons.

It tends not to be enough when:

  • You are starting from the letters, where every sound needs checking.
  • You are learning tajweed and need to know whether you are applying it correctly.
  • You are memorising the Qur’an, where a mistake learnt early is repeated in every revision.
  • The learner is a child, who will rarely notice their own errors and may lose interest without someone to read to.

Adults who once read but have not for years are a case of their own. Many can get going again with recordings, but it is worth having a teacher listen at least once, to catch habits that may have crept in.

Using both: a simple pattern

For most families, the question is not which to choose but how to combine them. A pattern that works for many learners:

  1. Learn and be corrected in the lesson

    New letters, rules and ayahs are read aloud to the teacher, who corrects them on the spot.

  2. Listen at home

    Between lessons, listen to a reciter reading the same passage, so the correct sound is the one in your ear.

  3. Practise what was set

    Read the passage the teacher set, a little each day, rather than moving ahead on your own.

  4. Bring questions back

    Anything that sounded unsure goes back to the teacher in the next lesson.

How it works at Radiance

Lessons are live and one-to-one on Zoom, so the learner reads aloud and is corrected throughout. The same teacher teaches your child every week, and after every lesson you receive a written report. Lessons are not recorded, to protect children; if your family would like a recording, you can ask for one.

Questions parents ask

Can I teach myself to read the Qur’an?

You can learn a good deal on your own, especially by listening. But to know your reading is correct, you need someone who hears you recite and corrects you.

Is a Qur’an app enough for my child?

An app is a helpful extra for listening and revision. On its own it cannot hear and correct a child’s mistakes, so it works well alongside a teacher.

Are recorded Qur’an lessons as good as live classes?

Recorded lessons are good for explanation and revision. Live lessons add the part recordings cannot: a teacher who hears you and corrects you.

What is talaqqi?

Talaqqi means learning the Qur’an by hearing it from a teacher and reciting it back to them for correction. It is the traditional way the Qur’an has been taught.

Can adults learn tajweed from videos?

Videos can explain the rules well. Applying them correctly in your own recitation is much easier with a teacher listening.

Sources

  1. Sahih al-Bukhari 5000

Book the first lesson

Thirty minutes with the teacher who will go on teaching your child, reading aloud and being corrected from the first minute. Free, with no card and no commitment.

Book the first lesson